Part Two
There's More To It than English
To write something, anything, you have to
start down very deep near where thought becomes language. You
have a discouragingly long way to go before you reach the point
where you can make yourself at all understood to someone else.
There, you hope, your reader starts the trip back down his own
long trail of language to thought and meaning. It's astonishing
that it should be possible to accomplish anything at all by such
a process. It only works because people share some kind of animal
consciousness. Maybe that explains why the search for
extraterrestrial intelligence, statistically certain to exist,
hasn't turned up anything. The signals coming up from a mindness
we can't share are indistinguishable to us from noise. What my
Chinese students wrote for their assignments always was plainly
recognizable as intelligence, but decoding it often seemed to
lead far away to some utterly alien thoughtscape.
Some samples. One of the tricks I tried to
teach them was the use of illustration to put substance into
abstractions. I had them read an apology for the American military
presence in Europe (something I also hoped would start some
flaming arguments, but didn't). The assignment was to write an
illustration, using some kind of real example, of how we often
have to do something we don't like. Here's one response:
First,
women are not allowed to keep bare head (of course,
except some disease) if you are not a nun. If you have
you hair cut without remaining hair, people will say that
you are not satisfied with Communist Party.
Second (last one), the Middle
School Students are forbidden to make love, because if
students make love during to middle School, that will
influence their study. One more a point, the students in
this period are not mature, they don't know the real
meaning of love. If they make love in this period, their
teacher or parents will regard that as a terrible matter
and give them all kinds of warning. In some middle
schools, if the student make love with boy or girl, the
school will dismiss them from school. But, I think, with
the development of society, this opinion will disappear.
In my opinion, if the students make love at the base of
helping each other to do well in study, that's OK!
Let's hair it for the Party, make love for
grades. The Chinese college junior twists between his own unique
set of social imperatives and appetites.
Another assignment was to figure out and
describe exactly how a certain presentation caught the student's
interest. That didn't work as intended. Almost everybody looked
in the window and saw only his own reflection. Such as:
"Me" is the actress in the film,
She was a thin. small. short and pretty girl, Her beauty
focused a lot of man, to ran after her, but she was very
proud and tended to think she was the best and always
looked down upon the others, at lest, she was published
by the God!
Oh, my dear teacher, What I have
said, I just made up a film at that time, because I was
waken up by the struck of 1, It was nothing but a dream!
One more specimen, this time a
self-comparison to another person:
To be fair, I must say that most of my
English majors did much better mechanically than this one, but
the outpouring of autocastigation was universal, quite at odds
with their typical rowdy goodnaturedness. They are sieved through
an education and upbringing that sorts all experience and
response into separate, rigidly correct bins. Speech and essay
contests invariably spawn predictable dithyrambs to principles,
among which most strikingly absent are life, liberty, and the
pursuit of happiness. A teacher's first duty is to preach what is
right. After one of my more romantic performances, a student came
up to me and asked, "Prof. Lee, what should we learn from
this?" I had left off the moral, all that really mattered.
The best I could come up with was "well, what did you
learn from it?" I like to think she's still wondering.
Outside of class, every paleface in China
quickly gets used to the let's-practice-our-English routine. The
opening gambit is standardized. You are from what country, have
you ever been to China before, how long have you been here? If
you haven't fled or played dumb, by now you're the center of a
crowd, all of whom know and simply have to try out at least those
three. There must be a universal English primer somewhere that
begins with them. Very few seem to have gone on to page 2, but
there are some surprises:
In the market street. A tiny, ancient man
threading among the tangle of sidewalk food piles, squatting
vendors, bicycles. Thin white hair, shabby blue jacket, cloth
slippers gone through at the toe. A cane in one hand, in the
other a plastic bag, two small fish, leeks, garlic. Suddenly he
turns to me, as though aware of my eyes on his bent back.
"Are you an American?" he inquires, very precisely. Half a dozen bristles on lip and chin. How to take a Vacation in China
The Fall semester at Gongda, as its inmates
dub Changsha Tech (zhong nan gong ye da xue), never really ended. Everybody just lost
interest in it. The weather gets seriously foul towards
Christmas, and that helps make the locals feel like celebrating.
After mid-December, classes couldn't outdraw the banquets.
Official China runs on the solar year, but what counts in real
life is the old lunar cycle of rites and seasons, still printed
on every Chinese calendar along with that newfangled Gregorian
nonsense. Of course, there's no sense in letting any holidays go
to waste, so Santa Claus and the reindeer do their act and auld
acquaintance gets baptized with fireworks and -water too, but
really just as a warmup for Spring Festival, which starts the
lunar new year (January 29 in 1987). To celebrate you go
home and eat.
Family and food have outlasted every
dynasty and doctrine to remain the two institutions Chinese life
is founded on. People show how they love both by what they're
willing to go through to celebrate them at chun jie. A
Chinese would see in the most insane holiday congestion Americans
can create a model of sedate efficiency compared to the shoving,
spitting tumult he tangles with every day. When all billion of
them are trying to get home for Spring Festival dinner, the
antipodes groan on their axes. And the foreign devils on the
teaching staff, let off from spreading bourgeois liberalization
for awhile, have nothing to do but travel.
Huddled under our roaring heat pump in
sweaters and parkas, Julia and I ruled anything outside the
tropics de facto suicide. How far south can you go in China? That
question, like many another, turned out to have both geographical
and political answers. Maps printed in China enclose the whole
South China Sea in a big red bubble, claiming every coral reef
(and the oil under them) almost down to the equator. The airline
map led us to believe a flight went as far as the southern tip of
Hainan Island, which just about everybody agrees is part of
China, and I found some promoganda shots of coconut palms and
beaches there. Sold.
After Christmas, as we got down to
banqueting in earnest, Zuo Tieyong, a Gongda vice-president,
heard of our project over a toast, and immediately took things in
hand. We were still learning that that's how things are
done--indeed the only hope of getting anything done: through
connections. The Nonferrous Metals Corporation, Gongda's parent
ministry, has research branches on Hainan and in Guangzhou, where
Zuo was owed some favors. A phone call tomorrow would command
their hospitality, no trouble at all. They would be only too
pleased to bed and banquet me, honored guest, first exchange
professor in our new program, its pioneer, the Head of the
Dragon. Bottoms up!
Now I had both the key to the tropics and a
Chinese name, Professor Lee Longtou (Lee Dragonhead). The latter, jovially honorific (serious prestige attaches to dancing the parade dragon's head), stuck, and is good for all sorts of respectful hilarity. The former would take some twisting.
A conference delegation was headed south in
a few days. They could take us along, get us tickets at the
native price, and someone from Guangzhou Research would meet the
plane. Fine.
The Gongda minibus tore along for the
airport flat out between the buttonwood trees, the fastest I had
ever moved in China, dodging trucks, pigs, mountains, children,
and even missing a few of the potholes. I wondered how many flips
it could do with a blown tire, in this land so famous for its
acrobats.
All for naught. Nothing blew, nothing flew
that morning. The flight, rumored for 7:40, deferred, as usual,
to the usual near-freezing drizzle. By lunchtime I was shaking
too hard to steer chopsticks and turned to drink. Sometime that
dim afternoon we did go, though, and the first thing I really
remember noticing at the Guangzhou airport was a nice pair of
legs in hose and skirt. My god, what has she done with her
quilting?
But that problem would have to wait. There
was no sign of our appointed escort, hardly a surprise for a
flight 8 hours late. Ah, connections. Cheng Zhongwen, Gongda
Foreign Languages chairman and accompanying delegate, had them
too. We taxied to the hotel where Nonferrous Metals keeps an
export headquarters. The phone worked. By dinnertime we had moved
into the VIP suite at the Guangzhou Research Institute, out in
the suburbs, guests of Mr. Shen Wenrong, Vice-Chief Engineer,
Ret., a man I like very much and will tell you more about in a
minute. I was going to learn a lot from him.
Our quarters were as severely Chinese as
could be. A great wall, no joke, encircles the institute, like
any such unit really a small city, with 3 gates and guardhouses
manned or womaned day and night. You neither come nor go
unnoticed, although access is public, with no badges or saluting
nonsense. The gatekeepers, like their counterparts everywhere,
are first of all service people, and in my experience very
willing and sometimes even able to fix or find or call or fetch.
They have a phone and the keys. They could instantly turn the
whole place into the equivalent of a medieval fortress. The
threat is expected from without.
Walled subcompounds are the functional organs in the Chinese soma, in the present example enclosing apartment complexes, factories, utility stations, a motor pool, a slum, fish ponds, banana, palm, orange, and azalea groves, the guest house. That last doesn't connote right. In Chinese cities, people don't live in what we would call a house.
A dwelling means a concrete multistory
blockhouse kind of thing with wee balconies cluttered with gutted
critters drying and laundry and flowers and junk, and apartments
scarcely less wee and communal--well, sanitary holes, if any,
down the hall, and open drains spewing up and down the walls
outside and broken windows and friendly, eager rats and a
resident party warden and the stairwells always wet and full of
bicycles and shouting and spitting and honeycomb coke blocks and
the whole thing just smells right, like home. But a guest house
is more ambitious than that. Mr. Shen assured us our suite was
"ministry-level."
The sitting room could hold a committee on
the plastic-covered furniture lining the walls in typically
severe rectangular arrangement. Lace mosquito nets swooped from
the ceiling over clean, hard beds. A shower room with tiled floor
and drain also contained a flush toilet, otherwise unenclosed,
and a demand water heater, alas, that demanded more current than
the wires draped rakishly around the roof gutters were willing to
carry. We never saw a rat.
Banqueting started right away. Its intent
is not to nourish but to stun. What creepeth, flyeth, swimmeth,
shooteth forth or oozeth about where or howsoever, that shalt
thou eat. What biteth like a serpent and stingeth like an adder
and stinketh like drain cleaner, that shalt thou drink. And all
shall be in quantity at least fourteen times what those gathered
together could possibly finish. And let host and guest not fail
to praise one another. Then go to bed.
Dawn struck with bugle blasts,
loudspeakered harangues and martial music, barnyard commotion,
much splashing, and a hell of a roar. The guesthouse overlooked
the wall, beyond which began peasantry. Producing food is what
China takes most seriously. They go at it with alarming
organization and energy--I do wish they'd turn all the public
services over to a peasant commune. At an airfield across the
road, somebody came out every morning and fired up the A-50, a
huge crate of a vintage-Russian biplane the Red Baron would have
been scared to fly. It made a stirring thunder for about 10
minutes. It even took off once. There wasn't fuel, I since heard,
for more.
Mr. Shen programed our day. We could give
him our red cards, white cards, green cards--no, he didn't need
the green ones--passports, and 300 Yuan, and he would get us
plane tickets for our further explorations. Did we know the
Guangzhou Botanical Garden was larger than any but Kew? No. Well,
it's right down the road.
It's big all right. All the usual vegetable
wonders, beginning with the justly famous avenue of
Archontophoenix, like living Gothic, groves of Caryotas and
Livistonas and Arecas and Phoenixes (palms, unlike the bird, can indeed be plural), a deliciously jungliferous fern arbor, gravely
beautiful bamboo forests. Despite the native tropicals, I didn't
think it matched Berlin (every known Tillandsia!). I have yet to
see Kew.
Over that evening's banquet, Mr. Shen told
us he had come home to retire from a six-year hitch with the UN
Industrial Development Organization in Vienna. When he
occasionally got stuck in English, he could get unstuck and carry
on in quite serviceable German. He had also visited Rome and
Paris. Wasn't that, I asked cautiously, a rather uncommonly
fortunate experience record? I knew that to work, study , or
travel abroad headed the list of fond hopes held by many of my
Changsha colleagues and students, anyone who had never succeeded
in unlatching all the catches to getting out of China, and most
of those few who had. Yes, he thoughtfully supposed, he had
enjoyed some privileges. I should understand, though, that China
was very different from other countries, that their free
enterprise and development looked very attractive, but that
thanks to socialism China had no crime or prostitution or drugs,
the ills inseparable from the capitalist system.
He went on so sincerely I decided it would
be impolite to argue with such surprising facts and feats of
logic. I said I thought our way of doing things made for
efficiency by competition, that any private airline, for example,
would put CAAC (Civil Air Administration of China) out of
business overnight.
"Yes," he smiled, "very
different." He slowly patted the back of his left hand with
his right, rather like a priest spending absolution. "China
is poor, and many things are hard here. Very hard."
We left it at that and did what we could
with the sea slugs, turtle, spicy sliced flesh things, shredded
kohlrabi and pig stomach, wiggly rubber fungoids, assorted weird
weeds and a dozen more platters of I know not and would rather
know not what. Then came the rice and vats of soup and the hot
pot, a thing like a big cake pan with a charcoal fire in the
middle. You dump in the soup and any stray scraps or unwary
bystanders and little unpeeled shrimp and wads of cilantro and
spinach and thin-sliced raw pork and it all boils merrily while
you snap at whatever you hope to fish out with chopsticks, and
everybody gets little liqueur glasses of icky sweet red wine and
rancid-smelling white booze and volleys toast for toast until the
oranges are served, and that means it's about over and time to go
to bed.
Guangzhou is a real city, somewhere in
China's top several sizewise, and otherwise at least a little
like what a Westerner means by civilization, lying there
helplessly exposed to Hong Kong TV, swarms of so-called overseas
Chinese, and the leapfrogging vanguards of businessmen breaching
socialist purity with dollars and decadence. Often in January it
was the only mainland Chinese station reporting temperature
minima above freezing. A Ming Dynasty fort, sharing a hilltop in
the park with a skypoking TV tower and Araucarias the size of
mature loblollies, houses a thorough display of archeologicalia
from the Paleolithic on the ground floor, where Mr. Shen, patting
his hand, pointed out that ancient Mexican civilization came from
China, up to the heroes of liberation on the fifth, from the
porch of which there must have been, B(efore) S(mog), a fine view
of the city where since the Mongols most Chinese revolutions get
started. There are also old temples and a mosque and a Catholic
cathedral ("stone house" in Chinese) and the cracked
Victorian elegance of the old opium-trading commercial quarter,
now dominated by the ridiculously stupendous White Swan Hotel
(welcome you please pay in foreign currency), and a well-swarmed
river walk, and huge, root-twining banyans, and Bauhinia trees
blooming everywhere and smelling distractingly seductive through
the diesel smoke, and a screeching tangle of traffic.
"You know, we don't have private
cars," Shen told me proudly. "I think that is
better." Score one more for socialism, I said to myself.
Chinese cities have grown up innocent of the automobile. But here
it comes, and the fight is awesome. Nothing seems to me more
likely to batter down the highminded puritanicality of modern
Chinese society than the Toyota.
I raised at least a couple of book-sized
issues in that last sentence. Please keep your seat while I bunt
this time up, and I promise we'll be off to the islands directly.
Recently, Zhao Ziyang, for the moment
China's most visible statesman, predicted that within a few years
China would become the world's greatest market for motor
vehicles. The auto makers no doubt are tooling up to replace St.
Christopher with little plastic dashboard Zhaos, praying he's
right. If I know my socialism, what he meant was that China is
going to build its own cars and flood the rest of the world with
fleets of them too. The latter may turn out to be more feasible
than the former.
Chinese society looks to me ultimately
composed of incredibly tight home-family-school-work-unit atoms
within which there's no place to go, much less park. The
automobile has shown how easily it can blast open old social
structures. In New China, everything depends on the cohesion and
governability of those vital cells. If people suddenly decide
they want the freedom to go wherever and whenever they please,
the system will break. They will also start doing and thinking
and wanting whatever they please, and all those plagues now so
feared and so anxiously screened out at the border will be let
loose inside, and everything the Revolution has fought for, the
control, the discipline, the righteousness, will be spoiled.
China will be pure no more. We'll soon see.
Now what about our expedition to the beach?
Oh, Shen apologized. No tickets. Flights to Haikou all full.
Haikou? That's the harbor on the north end
of the island. We were trying for the south sea shores at Sanya,
the most nearly equatorial PRC civilization. Shen never exactly
said so, but I'm sure he felt responsible for networking us along
within the Corporation, to its research unit in Haikou, where of
course there would be a guest house fit for VIPs and white folks.
Forfend we should be cast adrift, beyond connections! But we had
our minds made up to get to the beach, and we weren't going back
to our walk-in freezer in Changsha without having another shot at
it. We retrieved all our documents from Shen, and then, just for
the hell of it, went next morning ourselves to the China
International Travel Service in Guangzhou.
Just finding the gate in the chainlink
fence around the corner from the parking lot took some fancy
navigating. In the office, behind a long counter, five clerks
manned desks. No other customers. No stampeding, elbowing,
shoving hordes. Strange.
One clerk even noticed us. Getting stranger.
I guess it was the challenge. I knew better
than to waste any wattage getting mad. We hiked around a
kilometer of fence and lot to the airline office, geographically
just next door, and there they all were, the stampeding,
elbowing, shoving hordes. Julia elbowed and shoved to what
advertised itself as an information counter. An old bluejacketed
and capped functionary looked up in alarm. "Oooh," he
hooted, eyes wide, handing her a mimeo form. It asked for flight
number and time and destination and the like. Well, I had always
thought that was the kind of data information counters gave out,
but this is China. We had a slightly obsolete airline schedule a
friend had stolen for us somewhere--that's not the sort of thing
the airline wants you to have. We wrote in some numbers, fought
our way to a ticket window, and an hour later, behold, were
booked the next morning for Sanya. One way. No return ticket. No
hotel. Whatthehell.
I don't quite know what should come next.
The empty shack on the otherwise empty beach where the plane came
down, the bus ride in search of town (town?), wrangling
pediscooter vultures squabbling to loot the helpless white prey,
the utterly disintertested boy frontdesking the hostel totally
full of sourly idealistic foreign-devil backpackers, the frank
enmity at the fancy beach hotel on the other side of the
mountain, the hilarity I caused with my notion of getting plane
tickets out of there, all went by so uniformly depressingly that
they hardly seem now to have been separate events at all. The
hotel clerk grumpily conceded us a room for one night against our
express promise to move on next day. We graciously promised.
And there was the beach. Just as improbably
gorgeous as the bait the hucksters print in the ads.
I must pause a moment till my heart come
back to me. I was born and grew up on a beach. And I have lived
to be crowded, pushed, insulted, ordered, and revolted off it.
That crucial line between us and the ocean we came from eons ago
we are now turning everywhere into a huge trap. The lure is
water, the ultimate vital fluid , the archamniotic running in
every living vein. Nothing angers me more than the sight of
futile humanity drawing battle lines on the beach. We have cause
to envy the whales. They have made it back. We are killing each
other trying.
We didn't see any whales. Elaborately bored
or maybe just frightened capitalist subadults, frantically
casual, sprawled or jogged or gymnasticated earnestly. A little
gray cruiser sent ashore a team-drilled, fit-looking squad, who
pointed and triangulated and signaled bravely with a huge red
flag. A TV video crew, incongruous in clothes and battery packs,
waded around in the sand, hunting a story. Their English was
about as good as our Chinese, and of course they had to try it
out on us. I don't think we made the evening news. In a way, it
was a relief to be just more white dogshit instead of the
spectacle from outer space. As custodian of passports, room key,
every cent to our names, and four delicately excellent pieces of
coral, I combed the tide line. Julia floated out into the South
China Sea like a small, blonde, free whale.
From the airline agent, snarling with
laughter at my wanting tickets, I had at least learned where the
bus station was, and had gotten tickets next day for Haikou, a
good 350 km to the north at the other end of the island, whither
we had so recently disdained to go, but which now looked like the
far keyhole back to civilization. We hoped to fly, boat or swim
back to Guangzhou from there. At 7:29 a.m., the 7:30 run began.
The big Mitsubishi diesel roared to life, so did the tape system
at about twice the horsepower, and the little straw-hatted
hominid in the seat in front of me threw up all over the oranges
and sprouting coconuts stacked in the aisle.
I was mad and scared. This was vacationing?
Ahead, I worried, after eight hours of pounding by road and tape
and vomit, would be the dismal chaos of a Chinese bus station in
a city I knew nothing whatever of, on an island thousands were
standing in line to leave.
As it turned out, I had it about right. But
the city made up for it, first of all the Overseas Chinese Hotel.
Buddha bless them. We staggered in off the bus. They didn't know
any English and it didn't occur to them to shake us out for
dollars. Room? sure. How long you want to stay? (giggle, shy
smile). Plane tickets? Sure, we get them for you. How about
tomorrow?
Julia says I cried. They put us back
together with clean beds, cold beer, service-with-a-giggle and
that feast of the gods, fresh seafood. In another, better age,
maybe we'd have been there yet. But the age and condition being
what they were, we dared not spurn such a rarity as plane
tickets, so we signed on for the Guangzhou flight the next
evening. That would give us most of a day to stuff down fresh
banana-sized prawns and see the town.
Haikou is a gem. There's the sea--you can
smell it. And the harbor--you can smell it too--full of vast,
solemn, incredible junks. And an intestinal tangle of streets--I
can smell them still--arcaded with fancifully balconied and
crenellated fronts, almost Paduan, but distinctly
Chinese-riotous. And a huge central park on a hill with tombs and
temples and coconut palms and flowers blooming everywhere. We
hiked all over town and the wharves and even risked stopping for
a few seconds to just look (in a moment all you can see is a wall
of staring, slack-jawed faces).
We got back and checked out of
the hotel through the middle of an absolutely deafening wedding.
Airport? The taxi drivers weren't interested. Not far enough. You
go with them, there--a stray minibus. How much? Oh, nonono, come
on, you come. By ten we were having hot showers at the vast Dong
Fang Hotel in Guangzhou.
Go to Part ThreeIn our country, there are many
regulations that people have to obey whether you like it
or not. In the following, I'd like to give two examples
to illustrate this:
Today, I've seen an very exciting
film, it's name is "Person, who is killing me"
From this topic, you must feel very reverse. Really?
I'm a un-self-conifidence no belief
very casual and strong sense of self-abased girl.
in a sense, I lack compititve. All these character lead
me in a tight corner. and and alsamt became to a each day
I was in low spirit and fear everything. When I lost the
hope of life A girl came to my life. her coming brought
absolutly changes. Her advantage nature gave me much
impression and It's also effective. not only from the
outward features but also his inner nature is tremendous
different comparing to mine. She is self-responsibility
very confidence and (determined) willpower, from a
subtlities of his action. all those can reveal to me.
Sooner or later I imitate her. with attention. of long
stand I gradually regain his marvou feature. and up to
now. I do everything full of my energy.
"Yes." I stoop to catch his words in the ambient uproar.
"When I studied English, long ago, my teacher, an Englishman, taught me to say `I'm sorry, but I don't know.' Now I have read in a book that you must say `I'm sorry, I don't know.' Is that correct, without `but'?"
"Yes, that's right. It's also correct with `but'."
"Which is more correct?"
A question I hear so often. "Without." To dodge is useless.
"Thank you. It is important to speak exactly." His steady gaze sparkles.
"You certainly do. Your English is excellent."
"Oh, no, I speak only well enough to be understood. I am pleased to have met you."
Smile, chuckle, thin brown handshake, and gone.
"Yes?" he said.
"We'd like to go to Sanya. Can you get us tickets?"
"No."
"Well, I hear there's a tourist hotel there--can you get us a reservation?"
"No."
"Now look--the airline schedule shows 5 flights a week down there and back--"
"You buy ticket next door." The CAAC office.
"Oh. Then can you get me reservations?"
"No."
"I don't much want to get stuck down there. Can't you--"
"You get there, you go to Sanya travel service. No problem."
"Can you give me their number or address?"
"No." He went back to his desk. Not so strange after all.